Hum Source Criticism

Evaluate source credibility using primary/secondary classification, internal/external criticism, triangulation, and misinformation detection. Use this skill when the user needs to assess whether information is trustworthy, evaluate research sources, fact-check claims, or detect misinformation — even if they say 'can I trust this source', 'is this real', 'how reliable is this data', or 'fact-check this for me'.

248 stars 30 forksResearch & Science

Install

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more)
npx skills add asgard-ai-platform/skills --skill hum-source-criticism
Manual install
git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/asgard-ai-platform/skills.git /tmp/skills
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cp -r /tmp/skills/hum-source-criticism ~/.claude/skills/hum-source-criticism

Personal skills live in ~/.claude/skills. Use .claude/skills in a project folder to share a skill with your team.

From the SKILL.md

# Source Criticism

## Overview

Source criticism is a systematic method for evaluating whether information is trustworthy. Originally from historical methodology, it's now essential for navigating an information environment flooded with misinformation, opinion-as-fact, and AI-generated content.

## Framework

```
IRON LAW: No Source Is Automatically Trustworthy

Every source — including academic journals, government data, and news from
reputable outlets — has potential biases, errors, and limitations. Credibility
is assessed, not assumed. "It's from the New York Times / 中央社" is not
sufficient — WHAT are they reporting, based on WHAT evidence, and do other
sources corroborate it?
```

### Source Classification

**Primary sources**: Direct evidence from the time/event (original documents, raw data, eyewitness accounts, original research, official records)

**Secondary sources**: Analysis or interpretation of primary sources (textbooks, review articles, news analysis, biographies)

**Tertiary sources**: Compilations of primary and secondary (encyclopedias, Wikipedia, databases) — starting points, not endpoints

### Four Tests of Source Credibility

**1. External Criticism** — Is the source authentic?
- Who created it? Are they who they claim to be?
- When was it created? Is the date consistent?
- Is it the original or has it been altered?
- Is the publication/platform reputable?

**2. Internal Criticism** — Is the content reliable?
Read the full skill on GitHub

Details

Skill name
hum-source-criticism
Path
hum-source-criticism/SKILL.md
License
MIT
Repo updated
6 June 2026

FAQ

What does the Hum Source Criticism skill do?

Evaluate source credibility using primary/secondary classification, internal/external criticism, triangulation, and misinformation detection. Use this skill when the user needs to assess whether information is trustworthy, evaluate research sources, fact-check claims, or detect misinformation — even if they say 'can I trust this source', 'is this real', 'how reliable is this data', or 'fact-check this for me'.

How do I install the Hum Source Criticism skill?

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more): npx skills add asgard-ai-platform/skills --skill hum-source-criticism. Skills go in ~/.claude/skills (personal) or .claude/skills (project), and Claude loads them automatically when a task matches the description.

Is Hum Source Criticism popular?

It lives in asgard-ai-platform/skills, which has 248 GitHub stars and 30 forks.

Related skills

Algo Ad Bidding

248

asgard-ai-platform/skills

Implement and select ad bidding strategies from manual CPC to automated target-CPA and target-ROAS. Use this skill when the user needs to choose a bidding strategy, set up automated bidding, or optimize bid parameters — even if they say 'what bidding strategy should I use', 'target CPA setup', or 'smart bidding configuration'.

Marketing, Sales & Business30

Algo Ad Budget

248

asgard-ai-platform/skills

Optimize advertising budget allocation across campaigns using marginal returns analysis. Use this skill when the user needs to distribute budget across multiple campaigns, optimize spend pacing, or maximize overall ROAS under budget constraints — even if they say 'how to split my ad budget', 'campaign budget optimization', or 'diminishing returns on ad spend'.

Marketing, Sales & Business30

Algo Ad Ctr

248

asgard-ai-platform/skills

Build CTR prediction models for estimating ad click-through rates from features. Use this skill when the user needs to predict click probability, build an ad ranking model, or evaluate ad creative performance — even if they say 'predict click rate', 'ad relevance scoring', or 'which ad will get more clicks'.

Marketing, Sales & Business30

Med Health

248

asgard-ai-platform/skills

Use when writing a medical or health news story — clinical research breakthroughs, public health alerts, drug approvals, epidemiology, health policy, patient stories, risk communication — from research papers, press releases, health authority statements, or interviews. Specializes the med-news-reporter workflow for health-beat discipline: relative risk framing, absolute baseline inclusion, evidence-hierarchy verification, deidentification protocol, and WHO suicide-reporting compliance. Triggers on phrases like '寫一篇醫學新研究', 'draft a health news piece', '整理流行病新聞', '幫我把這份臨床試驗結果寫成新聞', '健康新聞報導', 'wr

Research & Science30

Hum Critical Thinking

248

asgard-ai-platform/skills

Apply structured critical thinking — identifying claims, evidence, reasoning chains, hidden assumptions, and logical fallacies — to evaluate or construct specific written arguments rigorously. Use this skill when the user presents a concrete argument, claim, op-ed, research finding, or piece of reasoning to be analyzed for logical validity or flaws, even if they say 'is this argument valid', 'what logical fallacies are in this', or 'what assumptions am I making in this thesis'. Do NOT use for casual plan review, trip planning, project risk brainstorming, or pre-mortems — 'poke holes in my plan

Research & Science30

Med Sports

248

asgard-ai-platform/skills

Use when the user wants to write a sports news piece — game recaps, athlete profiles, league/rule changes, injury reports, trade announcements, doping/discipline coverage — from supplied material (box scores, interviews, official statements, stats, medical updates). Specializes med-news-reporter for the sports beat: era-adjusted stats, source vetting for sports data, medical/injury disclosure limits, athlete-as-public-figure doctrine, doping allegations vs. allegations, sports-betting sensitivity, and on-field performance ≠ off-field authority. Triggers on phrases like 'write up this game', 't

Research & Science30

Browse the most popular Claude skills, all research & science skills, or write your own with the skills generator.