Hum Critical Thinking

Apply structured critical thinking — identifying claims, evidence, reasoning chains, hidden assumptions, and logical fallacies — to evaluate or construct specific written arguments rigorously. Use this skill when the user presents a concrete argument, claim, op-ed, research finding, or piece of reasoning to be analyzed for logical validity or flaws, even if they say 'is this argument valid', 'what logical fallacies are in this', or 'what assumptions am I making in this thesis'. Do NOT use for casual plan review, trip planning, project risk brainstorming, or pre-mortems — 'poke holes in my plan

248 stars 30 forksResearch & Science

Install

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more)
npx skills add asgard-ai-platform/skills --skill hum-critical-thinking
Manual install
git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/asgard-ai-platform/skills.git /tmp/skills
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cp -r /tmp/skills/hum-critical-thinking ~/.claude/skills/hum-critical-thinking

Personal skills live in ~/.claude/skills. Use .claude/skills in a project folder to share a skill with your team.

From the SKILL.md

# Critical Thinking Framework

## Overview

Critical thinking systematically evaluates arguments by decomposing them into claims, evidence, reasoning, and assumptions. It identifies where arguments are strong, weak, or fallacious — not to "win" debates but to arrive at better-justified conclusions.

## Framework

```
IRON LAW: Separate the Argument from the Person

Evaluate the ARGUMENT (claim + evidence + reasoning), not the person
making it. A bad person can make a good argument. A trusted expert
can make a bad argument. Ad hominem (attacking the person) and appeal
to authority (trusting the person) are both fallacies.
```

### Argument Structure

Every argument has four components:
1. **Claim**: What is being asserted? (conclusion)
2. **Evidence**: What facts/data support the claim?
3. **Reasoning**: How does the evidence support the claim? (the logical bridge)
4. **Assumptions**: What unstated premises must be true for the reasoning to hold?

### Evaluation Steps

**Step 1: Identify the claim** — What exactly is being argued? Restate in one sentence.

**Step 2: Examine the evidence**
- Is it factual or anecdotal?
- Is it sufficient (enough data points)?
- Is it relevant (does it actually relate to the claim)?
- Is it current (not outdated)?
- Could the evidence support a different claim?

**Step 3: Evaluate the reasoning**
- Does the evidence logically lead to the claim?
- Are there logical fallacies? (see catalog below)
- Is correlation being mistaken for causation?
Read the full skill on GitHub

Details

Skill name
hum-critical-thinking
Path
hum-critical-thinking/SKILL.md
License
MIT
Repo updated
6 June 2026

FAQ

What does the Hum Critical Thinking skill do?

Apply structured critical thinking — identifying claims, evidence, reasoning chains, hidden assumptions, and logical fallacies — to evaluate or construct specific written arguments rigorously. Use this skill when the user presents a concrete argument, claim, op-ed, research finding, or piece of reasoning to be analyzed for logical validity or flaws, even if they say 'is this argument valid', 'what logical fallacies are in this', or 'what assumptions am I making in this thesis'. Do NOT use for casual plan review, trip planning, project risk brainstorming, or pre-mortems — 'poke holes in my plan

How do I install the Hum Critical Thinking skill?

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more): npx skills add asgard-ai-platform/skills --skill hum-critical-thinking. Skills go in ~/.claude/skills (personal) or .claude/skills (project), and Claude loads them automatically when a task matches the description.

Is Hum Critical Thinking popular?

It lives in asgard-ai-platform/skills, which has 248 GitHub stars and 30 forks.

Related skills

Algo Ad Bidding

248

asgard-ai-platform/skills

Implement and select ad bidding strategies from manual CPC to automated target-CPA and target-ROAS. Use this skill when the user needs to choose a bidding strategy, set up automated bidding, or optimize bid parameters — even if they say 'what bidding strategy should I use', 'target CPA setup', or 'smart bidding configuration'.

Marketing, Sales & Business30

Algo Ad Budget

248

asgard-ai-platform/skills

Optimize advertising budget allocation across campaigns using marginal returns analysis. Use this skill when the user needs to distribute budget across multiple campaigns, optimize spend pacing, or maximize overall ROAS under budget constraints — even if they say 'how to split my ad budget', 'campaign budget optimization', or 'diminishing returns on ad spend'.

Marketing, Sales & Business30

Algo Ad Ctr

248

asgard-ai-platform/skills

Build CTR prediction models for estimating ad click-through rates from features. Use this skill when the user needs to predict click probability, build an ad ranking model, or evaluate ad creative performance — even if they say 'predict click rate', 'ad relevance scoring', or 'which ad will get more clicks'.

Marketing, Sales & Business30

Hum Source Criticism

248

asgard-ai-platform/skills

Evaluate source credibility using primary/secondary classification, internal/external criticism, triangulation, and misinformation detection. Use this skill when the user needs to assess whether information is trustworthy, evaluate research sources, fact-check claims, or detect misinformation — even if they say 'can I trust this source', 'is this real', 'how reliable is this data', or 'fact-check this for me'.

Research & Science30

Grad Paradigms

248

asgard-ai-platform/skills

Apply Kuhn's paradigm theory to analyze scientific progress through the cycle of normal science, anomalies, crisis, and revolution. Use this skill when the user needs to understand why a field resists change, trace paradigm shifts in a discipline, analyze incommensurability between competing frameworks, or when they ask 'why do scientists ignore contradictory evidence', 'how do scientific revolutions happen', or 'why can't proponents of different paradigms agree'.

Research & Science30

Med Health

248

asgard-ai-platform/skills

Use when writing a medical or health news story — clinical research breakthroughs, public health alerts, drug approvals, epidemiology, health policy, patient stories, risk communication — from research papers, press releases, health authority statements, or interviews. Specializes the med-news-reporter workflow for health-beat discipline: relative risk framing, absolute baseline inclusion, evidence-hierarchy verification, deidentification protocol, and WHO suicide-reporting compliance. Triggers on phrases like '寫一篇醫學新研究', 'draft a health news piece', '整理流行病新聞', '幫我把這份臨床試驗結果寫成新聞', '健康新聞報導', 'wr

Research & Science30

Browse the most popular Claude skills, all research & science skills, or write your own with the skills generator.