Skill Reviewer

Reviews and evaluates an existing SKILL.md for quality, pedagogical soundness, persona compliance, and agent-readiness. Triggers when the user wants feedback on a skill they've written, wants to improve an existing skill, or wants to check whether a skill meets the Legal Ed Skills Hub standards.

48 stars 8 forksSoftware Development

Install

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more)
npx skills add harvard-lil/lawskills-hub --skill skill-reviewer
Manual install
git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/harvard-lil/lawskills-hub.git /tmp/lawskills-hub
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cp -r /tmp/lawskills-hub/skills/skill-developer/skill-reviewer ~/.claude/skills/skill-reviewer

Personal skills live in ~/.claude/skills. Use .claude/skills in a project folder to share a skill with your team.

From the SKILL.md

# Skill Reviewer

You help a **skill developer** evaluate and improve an existing SKILL.md. You review the skill across four dimensions -- format compliance, persona alignment, pedagogical quality, and agent-readiness -- and produce specific, actionable feedback.

## Tone

Constructive peer reviewer. Be direct and specific. Name what works well before identifying problems. Every critique should come with a concrete suggestion for improvement.

## Step 1: Obtain the Skill

Ask the user to provide the skill to review. They can:

- Paste the SKILL.md content directly
- Point to a file path (if you have access to the codebase)
- Describe the skill if they don't have the file handy (though a full review requires the actual text)

Also ask which **persona** this skill belongs to, if it isn't clear from the content. You need to know the persona's constraints to evaluate compliance.

The persona constraints are:

| Persona | Objective | Key constraint |
|---------|-----------|----------------|
| **Professor** | Improve the quality of legal education | Help design learning experiences, not produce student-facing work product |
| **Student** | Coach, encourage, and check understanding | Never produce finished work product the student would submit |
| **Pro Se** | Orient and connect | Never give legal advice; teach, orient, and empower |
| **CLE** | Coach and build skills | Build the attorney's own capabilities, not do work for them |

## Step 2: Review Format Compliance
Read the full skill on GitHub

Details

Skill name
skill-reviewer
Path
skills/skill-developer/skill-reviewer/SKILL.md
Repo updated
16 October 2026

FAQ

What does the Skill Reviewer skill do?

Reviews and evaluates an existing SKILL.md for quality, pedagogical soundness, persona compliance, and agent-readiness. Triggers when the user wants feedback on a skill they've written, wants to improve an existing skill, or wants to check whether a skill meets the Legal Ed Skills Hub standards.

How do I install the Skill Reviewer skill?

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more): npx skills add harvard-lil/lawskills-hub --skill skill-reviewer. Skills go in ~/.claude/skills (personal) or .claude/skills (project), and Claude loads them automatically when a task matches the description.

Is Skill Reviewer popular?

It lives in harvard-lil/lawskills-hub, which has 48 GitHub stars and 8 forks.

Related skills

Cle Meta

48

harvard-lil/lawskills-hub

Always-on assistant for practicing attorneys focused on professional development and continuing education. Triggers on professional development, skill building, learning new practice areas, client communication improvement, CLE planning, career development, or practice management improvement.

Software Development

Client Email Coach

48

harvard-lil/lawskills-hub

Triggers when a practicing attorney wants feedback on a draft email to a client, needs help improving client communication, or wants coaching on tone, clarity, or risk management in written client communications.

Productivity & Notes

Development Plan

48

harvard-lil/lawskills-hub

Triggers when a practicing attorney wants to create a professional development plan, set career goals, identify skill gaps, plan their CLE activities for the year, or think strategically about their career trajectory.

Software Development

Skill Tester

48

harvard-lil/lawskills-hub

Helps create rubrics and test scenarios for evaluating AI skills, and evaluates conversation traces against those rubrics. Triggers when the user wants to test a skill, write a rubric for a skill, evaluate whether a skill is working well, define quality criteria for a skill, or assess a conversation where a skill was used.

Software Development

Skill Developer Meta

48

harvard-lil/lawskills-hub

Always-on assistant for creating, reviewing, and testing pedagogical AI skills for the Legal Ed Skills Hub. Triggers on writing new skills, reviewing skill quality, evaluating skill pedagogy, testing skills against rubrics, defining evaluation criteria, or any task related to building and improving agent skills for legal education.

Software Development

D365fo CLI

49

dynamics365ninja/d365fo-cli

D365 Finance & Operations X++ AI development skill powered by the d365fo CLI. Use whenever the user is working in a D365 F&O X++ project: writing, reading, searching, reviewing, or debugging classes, tables, forms, CoC extensions, event handlers, entities, security, batch jobs, business events, labels, or any AOT artifact — including bug investigation and code-reading tasks, not just new authoring. Prefer `d365fo search`/`get`/`find` over Grep/Glob when locating or inspecting AOT objects. Points to the topic-specific d365fo skills installed next to it.

Software Development26

Browse the most popular Claude skills, all software development skills, or write your own with the skills generator.