Skeptical Triage

Reusable 3-round self-challenge + arbiter pattern for filtering false positives from findings/verdicts. Use when the cost of a false-positive gate block exceeds the cost of ~4 extra LLM turns.

38 stars 11 forksAI, LLMs & Agents

Install

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more)
npx skills add jeremybrasher/grokbot-skills --skill skeptical-triage
Manual install
git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/jeremybrasher/grokbot-skills.git /tmp/grokbot-skills
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cp -r /tmp/grokbot-skills/collections/great-cto/skills/skeptical-triage ~/.claude/skills/skeptical-triage

Personal skills live in ~/.claude/skills. Use .claude/skills in a project folder to share a skill with your team.

From the SKILL.md

# Skeptical Triage

Filter false positives from multi-angle review, security audit, QA regression flags, or any high-stakes judgment before it turns into a blocker.

Three rounds of skeptical self-review + an impartial arbiter, with a confidence score from the vote.

## When to invoke

| Caller | Finding type | Apply triage? |
|--------|--------------|---------------|
| `/review` | Angle 2/4/7/9 P0/P1 (security, SQL, privacy, concurrency) | Yes |
| `/review --deep` | Any angle P0/P1 | Yes |
| `security-officer` | CSO audit P0/P1 | Yes |
| `security-officer` | Secret in source/git, confirmed CVE | **No** — hard finding |
| `qa-engineer` | Flaky-test verdict (is this a regression or flake?) | Yes |
| `architect` | ADR trade-off dispute (option A vs. B when both look reasonable) | Yes |
| Any | P2/advisory | No |

## The 4-step pattern

Run these sequentially. Each round sees prior reasoning. Arbiter sees all rounds.

### Round 1 — Reachability / Premise

Question: **is the premise true?**
- For security/reliability: can an external attacker reach this code path with untrusted input? Trace input flow backward from the bug site to its origin. If only trusted internal callers → lean INVALID.
- For regressions: does the failing behavior reproduce from a clean state on the target branch?
- For ADR trade-offs: is the constraint that forces the choice actually binding? (e.g. "we need <10ms p99" — is that real or aspirational?)
Read the full skill on GitHub

Details

Skill name
skeptical-triage
Path
collections/great-cto/skills/skeptical-triage/SKILL.md
Repo updated
15 September 2026

FAQ

What does the Skeptical Triage skill do?

Reusable 3-round self-challenge + arbiter pattern for filtering false positives from findings/verdicts. Use when the cost of a false-positive gate block exceeds the cost of ~4 extra LLM turns.

How do I install the Skeptical Triage skill?

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more): npx skills add jeremybrasher/grokbot-skills --skill skeptical-triage. Skills go in ~/.claude/skills (personal) or .claude/skills (project), and Claude loads them automatically when a task matches the description.

Is Skeptical Triage popular?

It lives in jeremybrasher/grokbot-skills, which has 38 GitHub stars and 11 forks.

Related skills

Anti Patterns

38

jeremybrasher/grokbot-skills

Catalogue of known SDLC anti-patterns that great_cto agents must actively reject when reviewing architecture, plans, code, or post-mortems. Used by architect (pre-impl), pm (planning), senior-dev (impl), l3-support (post-incident).

Software Development11

Anydesign

38

jeremybrasher/grokbot-skills

Analyze images, websites, and Figma files to extract their design and generate a `design.md` with token system, component inventory, and reconstruction notes. Use this skill whenever the user wants to understand, document, replicate, or audit the design of something visual: a screenshot, a URL, a Figma link, a Pinterest reference, a mockup, a competitor's site, a component, a dashboard, a landing page. Also when they ask 'extract the design system from X', 'document the style of Y', 'analyze this visually', 'convert this image into tokens', 'help me replicate this design', 'what palette does t

Frontend & Design11

Archetype Review Base

38

jeremybrasher/grokbot-skills

Shared review framework that every domain reviewer (pci, oracle, gov, edtech, healthcare, mlops, etc.) MUST follow. Defines the output artifact (TM-{slug}.md), mandatory sections, severity scale, verdict format, the workflow scaffold (when-invoked, Step-0 read-inputs, HANDOFF), and the "domain heuristic vs generic check" boundary. Eliminates duplication across the ~30 reviewer prompts.

Finance & Crypto11

Vertical Restaurants

38

jeremybrasher/grokbot-skills

Domain-knowledge primer for the restaurants & hospitality vertical (dine-in, pickup, delivery). Gives architect and pm the vocabulary, non-obvious operating rules, must-model entities, and incumbent landscape so a restaurant-product spec isn't naive about modifiers, 86'd items, aggregator commissions, tip law, and razor-thin margins. Covers the 4 products: online-ordering, reservations, loyalty, shift-scheduling.

AI, LLMs & Agents11

Prose Style

38

jeremybrasher/grokbot-skills

Reusable writing-style contract for agent outputs (reports, ARCH docs, verdicts, threat models). Forces direct prose with concrete evidence, no marketing voice, no hedge words. The single most-referenced skill across the pipeline — used by 28 agents.

AI, LLMs & Agents11

Vibe Creating Prompt

38

jeremybrasher/grokbot-skills

Judges whether a user's input suits the Vibe Creating style of video-prompt writing, and when it does, distills single-scene prompts, multi-shot descriptions, emotional imagery, or mixed input into prompts that are easier for a video model to generate from — while preserving any user-specified dialogue, voiceover, music, sound effects, and other hard constraints. Use when a user wants to turn an idea, story, feeling, or rough/over-specified prompt into a strong text-to-video prompt (Seedance, Sora, Kling, Veo, Runway, etc.), or asks to "rewrite", "improve", "clean up", or "vibe-ify" a video pr

AI, LLMs & Agents11

Browse the most popular Claude skills, all ai, llms & agents skills, or write your own with the skills generator.