S4h Logic Council

Run a reasoning problem, argument, plan, or decision through a council of 5 logical reasoning advisors who analyze it from distinct reasoning frameworks, peer-review each other, and synthesize a verdict on whether the reasoning holds. MANDATORY TRIGGERS: 'logic council this', 'run the logic council', 'pressure-test this reasoning', 'is my thinking sound'. STRONG TRIGGERS: any complex argument where the conclusion matters, a plan with non-obvious dependencies, reasoning you've invested in and want stress-tested. Use ethics-council for moral questions, llm-council for general decisions — this co

242 stars 25 forksTesting & QA

Install

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more)
npx skills add human-avatar/skills-for-humanity --skill s4h-logic-council
Manual install
git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/human-avatar/skills-for-humanity.git /tmp/skills-for-humanity
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cp -r /tmp/skills-for-humanity/skills/s4h-logic-council ~/.claude/skills/s4h-logic-council

Personal skills live in ~/.claude/skills. Use .claude/skills in a project folder to share a skill with your team.

From the SKILL.md

# Logic Council

A single reviewer catches some flaws in reasoning. A council catches more — because different reasoning frameworks find different failure modes. Formal logic catches invalid inferences. Systems thinking catches missing feedback loops. Bayesian reasoning catches base-rate neglect. First principles reasoning catches assumptions dressed as facts. Adversarial logic catches the strongest counter-argument you haven't faced yet.

Run all five. Let them disagree. The synthesis tells you where your reasoning is load-bearing and where it's hollow.

---

## The Five Reasoning Frameworks

### 1. Formal Logic
Tests deductive structure. Are premises stated? Do they support the conclusion? Are necessary and sufficient conditions correctly identified? Finds: invalid inferences, unstated assumptions doing hidden work, conclusions that overreach their premises, equivocation across terms.

### 2. Systems Thinking
Treats the problem as a system with feedback loops, delays, and emergent properties. Asks: what happens over time? What non-linear effects appear at scale? What second and third-order consequences has the reasoning ignored? Finds: linear thinking applied to non-linear systems, missing feedback loops, unintended consequences, solutions that fix the proximate cause while worsening the root cause.

### 3. Bayesian Reasoning
Read the full skill on GitHub

Details

Skill name
s4h-logic-council
Path
skills/s4h-logic-council/SKILL.md
License
MIT
Repo updated
15 July 2026

FAQ

What does the S4h Logic Council skill do?

Run a reasoning problem, argument, plan, or decision through a council of 5 logical reasoning advisors who analyze it from distinct reasoning frameworks, peer-review each other, and synthesize a verdict on whether the reasoning holds. MANDATORY TRIGGERS: 'logic council this', 'run the logic council', 'pressure-test this reasoning', 'is my thinking sound'. STRONG TRIGGERS: any complex argument where the conclusion matters, a plan with non-obvious dependencies, reasoning you've invested in and want stress-tested. Use ethics-council for moral questions, llm-council for general decisions — this co

How do I install the S4h Logic Council skill?

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more): npx skills add human-avatar/skills-for-humanity --skill s4h-logic-council. Skills go in ~/.claude/skills (personal) or .claude/skills (project), and Claude loads them automatically when a task matches the description.

Is S4h Logic Council popular?

It lives in human-avatar/skills-for-humanity, which has 242 GitHub stars and 25 forks, and is included in 1 curated skill list.

Related skills

S4h

242

human-avatar/skills-for-humanity

Master orchestration skill. Takes any situation in plain English, identifies the underlying goal, designs a multi-skill reasoning workflow, and executes it sequentially — feeding each skill's output into the next. Use when you say 'help me think through this', 'I need to figure out what to do', 'where do I start', or any time you want structured thinking applied end-to-end rather than routed to a single tool.

Testing & QAIn 1 list25

S4h Aesthetic

242

human-avatar/skills-for-humanity

Entry point for the aesthetic toolkit. Routes to the right aesthetic skill based on your situation. Use when you say 'aesthetic', 'check the design', 'does this feel right', 'is this elegant', 'is this too complex', 'what pattern is this', 'find the simpler version', or want an aesthetic lens applied without knowing which specific tool fits.

OtherIn 1 list25

S4h Aesthetic Coherence Check

242

human-avatar/skills-for-humanity

Tests whether the parts of something form a unified whole — finding the jarring inconsistencies that accumulate when different contributors work without a shared vision. TRIGGERS: 'coherence check', 'does this feel unified', 'something feels off', 'inconsistent', 'check the whole', 'does this hang together'.

Testing & QAIn 1 list25

S4h Logic Fixer

242

human-avatar/skills-for-humanity

Take broken reasoning — a flawed argument, contradictory spec, unsound plan, or invalid inference — diagnose exactly what's wrong, and produce a corrected version. Use when you have reasoning that doesn't hold and you want it fixed, not just critiqued. TRIGGERS: 'fix this reasoning', 'repair this argument', 'this logic is broken, fix it', 'make this argument sound', 'my reasoning is circular, help', any situation where broken reasoning needs to be made valid rather than just flagged. Pairs with logic-argument-validation (which diagnoses) and logic-council (which pressure-tests) — this skill fi

Testing & QAIn 1 list25

S4h Logic Check

242

human-avatar/skills-for-humanity

A fast, comprehensive logic report on any argument, plan, or reasoning — validates premises, tests inference, detects fallacies, surfaces hidden assumptions, and produces a verdict. Lighter than logic-council (no peer review), heavier than logic-argument-validation (covers the whole reasoning, not just one argument). Triggers: 'logic check', 'quick logic review', 'check my reasoning', 'is this sound', 'full logic check', any request for a complete logical assessment.

Testing & QAIn 1 list25

S4h Probability Confidence Calibration

242

human-avatar/skills-for-humanity

Tests whether stated confidence levels match available evidence — catching overconfidence and underconfidence. Use when asked to 'calibrate my confidence', 'am I overconfident', 'confidence check', 'how sure should I be', or 'is this as certain as it seems'.

Testing & QAIn 1 list25

Browse the most popular Claude skills, all testing & qa skills, or write your own with the skills generator.