S4h Investigation Counter Hypothesis

Generates the best alternative explanations for the same observations. Use when you have a claim or explanation and want to know whether something else could explain the evidence just as well — 'could there be another explanation', 'what else could cause this', 'am I sure this isn't something else', 'steel-man the alternative', 'what would a skeptic say', 'rival hypotheses'.

242 stars 25 forksFinance & Crypto

Install

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more)
npx skills add human-avatar/skills-for-humanity --skill s4h-investigation-counter-hypothesis
Manual install
git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/human-avatar/skills-for-humanity.git /tmp/skills-for-humanity
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cp -r /tmp/skills-for-humanity/skills/s4h-investigation-counter-hypothesis ~/.claude/skills/s4h-investigation-counter-hypothesis

Personal skills live in ~/.claude/skills. Use .claude/skills in a project folder to share a skill with your team.

From the SKILL.md

# Investigation: Counter-Hypothesis

The confirmation trap is automatic: once we have an explanation, we look for evidence that supports it and stop looking for evidence that would support alternatives. Counter-hypothesis generation is the structural antidote. The process is not to argue against your explanation — it is to seriously generate the best competing explanations and then ask: given all the evidence, which hypothesis should I actually believe? The decisive test — the observation that, if run, would most clearly discriminate between hypotheses — is the product.

---

## Your Process

**Step 1: State the Hypothesis Under Investigation**
Write out the claim or explanation you are currently working with:
- What is being explained? (The observations, pattern, or outcome)
- What does the hypothesis assert is causing, driving, or explaining it?
- What evidence is currently cited in support?

**Framing check:** Confirm the specific hypothesis before continuing. State what you've identified — the claim being tested, what it purports to explain, and what evidence is cited for it — in one sentence, then use `AskUserQuestion`:
- **Question:** "I'm reading this as: [your one-sentence framing of the hypothesis, the observations it explains, and the key evidence]. Is that right?"
- **Header:** "Framing"
- **Options:**
  - **Yes — proceed** — framing is correct
  - **Adjust** — one element is off; user will correct it before you continue
Read the full skill on GitHub

Details

Skill name
s4h-investigation-counter-hypothesis
Path
skills/s4h-investigation-counter-hypothesis/SKILL.md
License
MIT
Repo updated
15 July 2026

FAQ

What does the S4h Investigation Counter Hypothesis skill do?

Generates the best alternative explanations for the same observations. Use when you have a claim or explanation and want to know whether something else could explain the evidence just as well — 'could there be another explanation', 'what else could cause this', 'am I sure this isn't something else', 'steel-man the alternative', 'what would a skeptic say', 'rival hypotheses'.

How do I install the S4h Investigation Counter Hypothesis skill?

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more): npx skills add human-avatar/skills-for-humanity --skill s4h-investigation-counter-hypothesis. Skills go in ~/.claude/skills (personal) or .claude/skills (project), and Claude loads them automatically when a task matches the description.

Is S4h Investigation Counter Hypothesis popular?

It lives in human-avatar/skills-for-humanity, which has 242 GitHub stars and 25 forks, and is included in 1 curated skill list.

Related skills

S4h

242

human-avatar/skills-for-humanity

Master orchestration skill. Takes any situation in plain English, identifies the underlying goal, designs a multi-skill reasoning workflow, and executes it sequentially — feeding each skill's output into the next. Use when you say 'help me think through this', 'I need to figure out what to do', 'where do I start', or any time you want structured thinking applied end-to-end rather than routed to a single tool.

Testing & QAIn 1 list25

S4h Aesthetic

242

human-avatar/skills-for-humanity

Entry point for the aesthetic toolkit. Routes to the right aesthetic skill based on your situation. Use when you say 'aesthetic', 'check the design', 'does this feel right', 'is this elegant', 'is this too complex', 'what pattern is this', 'find the simpler version', or want an aesthetic lens applied without knowing which specific tool fits.

OtherIn 1 list25

S4h Aesthetic Coherence Check

242

human-avatar/skills-for-humanity

Tests whether the parts of something form a unified whole — finding the jarring inconsistencies that accumulate when different contributors work without a shared vision. TRIGGERS: 'coherence check', 'does this feel unified', 'something feels off', 'inconsistent', 'check the whole', 'does this hang together'.

Testing & QAIn 1 list25

S4h Investigation Evidence Audit

242

human-avatar/skills-for-humanity

Evaluates the quality, strength, and completeness of evidence for a claim. Covers evidence type hierarchy, sample quality, methodological soundness, conflicts of interest, and what's notably absent. Use when you want to know how good the evidence is — 'is this evidence strong', 'evaluate the research', 'how solid is this', 'is this just one study', 'what kind of evidence supports this', 'what's missing from the evidence'.

Finance & CryptoIn 1 list25

S4h Investigation Claim Decomposition

242

human-avatar/skills-for-humanity

Breaks a complex claim into its smallest independently verifiable parts, classifies each sub-claim, and identifies which parts carry the most logical load. Use when a claim feels too big to verify as a unit — 'what exactly is this claiming', 'break this down', 'what are the hidden assumptions in this statement', 'this seems like multiple claims at once', 'what would I need to verify to believe this'.

Finance & CryptoIn 1 list25

S4h Investigation Source Trace

242

human-avatar/skills-for-humanity

Traces a claim back to its origin: who first made it, what evidence it rested on, and how it has been distorted in transmission. Use when you've heard something and want to know where it actually came from — 'where does this claim come from', 'who first said this', 'I've heard that X is true', 'trace the source', 'is this just a rumor', 'how did this become conventional wisdom'.

Finance & CryptoIn 1 list25

Browse the most popular Claude skills, all finance & crypto skills, or write your own with the skills generator.