Questions Are Not Instructions

Engage with what the user said before taking action. Triggers on: questions ('?'), feedback ('this is wrong', 'that doesn't look right', 'there are issues'), challenges ('why did you', 'have you considered'), criticism ('this isn't working', 'I don't like'), observations ('I notice', 'it seems like'), naming a skill or concept. STOP and respond to the user's actual words before doing anything.

365 stars 47 forksOther Plugin marketplace

Install

Claude Code plugin
/plugin marketplace add NTCoding/claude-skillz

The repo is a Claude Code plugin marketplace. Run /plugin afterwards to pick the plugin that includes this skill.

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more)
npx skills add NTCoding/claude-skillz --skill questions-are-not-instructions
Manual install
git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/NTCoding/claude-skillz.git /tmp/claude-skillz
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cp -r /tmp/claude-skillz/questions-are-not-instructions ~/.claude/skills/questions-are-not-instructions

Personal skills live in ~/.claude/skills. Use .claude/skills in a project folder to share a skill with your team.

From the SKILL.md

# Engage Before Acting

When the user says something, engage with what they said. Don't jump to action.

## The Problem

When users give feedback, ask questions, or make observations, you interpret them as **indirect instructions** and immediately start doing things:
- "Will that really work?" → you abandon the approach
- "Have you considered X?" → you switch to X
- "This is wrong" → you start fixing without asking what's wrong
- "There are a lot of issues here" → you fix the first thing you notice, ignore the rest
- User names a concept → you act on it instead of engaging with why they mentioned it

**This is wrong.** Engage first. Act second.

## The Rule

🚨 **Before acting on ANYTHING the user says, engage with it. Answer questions literally. Ask about feedback. Clarify criticism. Then ask what they want you to do.**

## When This Activates

- User asks a question (contains '?')
- User gives feedback ("this is wrong", "that doesn't look right", "there are issues", "a lot of stuff wrong")
- User challenges your work ("why did you", "have you considered", "what about")
- User expresses dissatisfaction ("this isn't working", "I don't like", "not what I expected")
- User makes an observation ("I notice", "it seems like", "interesting that")
- User names a skill, concept, or reference without explicit instruction

## What To Do

1. Acknowledge what they said
2. Respond to the LITERAL content — answer the question, ask about the feedback, engage with the observation
Read the full skill on GitHub

Details

Skill name
questions-are-not-instructions
Path
questions-are-not-instructions/SKILL.md
Repo updated
24 March 2026

FAQ

What does the Questions Are Not Instructions skill do?

Engage with what the user said before taking action. Triggers on: questions ('?'), feedback ('this is wrong', 'that doesn't look right', 'there are issues'), challenges ('why did you', 'have you considered'), criticism ('this isn't working', 'I don't like'), observations ('I notice', 'it seems like'), naming a skill or concept. STOP and respond to the user's actual words before doing anything.

How do I install the Questions Are Not Instructions skill?

Claude Code plugin: /plugin marketplace add NTCoding/claude-skillz. Skills go in ~/.claude/skills (personal) or .claude/skills (project), and Claude loads them automatically when a task matches the description.

Is Questions Are Not Instructions popular?

It lives in NTCoding/claude-skillz, which has 365 GitHub stars and 47 forks.

Related skills

Architect Refine Critique

365

NTCoding/claude-skillz

Three-phase design review. Chain architect → refiner → critique subagents. Triggers on: 'design review', 'architecture review', '/arc', system design proposals, significant refactoring decisions, new service or module design.

Software Development47

Challenge That

365

NTCoding/claude-skillz

Force critical evaluation of proposals, requirements, or decisions by analyzing from multiple adversarial perspectives. Triggers on: accepting a proposal without pushback, 'sounds good', 'let's go with', design decisions with unstated tradeoffs, unchallenged assumptions, premature consensus. Invoke with /challenge-that.

Software Development47

Concise Output

365

NTCoding/claude-skillz

Enforces brevity and signal-over-noise in all outputs. Eliminates verbose explanations, filler phrases, and unnecessary elaboration. Triggers on: every response (governs output length and density when loaded).

Other47

Switch Persona

365

NTCoding/claude-skillz

Quick persona switching. Triggers: 'switch persona', 'switch to X', 'become X'. Lists personas, reads selected file, switches immediately.

Other47

Critical Peer Personality

365

NTCoding/claude-skillz

Professional, skeptical communication style. Never over-enthusiastic, verifies before agreeing, challenges constructively, proposes instead of asking preferences. Expert peer who coaches, not serves. Triggers on: composing responses, agreeing with user, making recommendations, giving feedback.

Other47

Web Access

341

mingchen666/Reviva

所有联网操作必须通过此 skill 处理,包括:搜索、网页抓取、登录后操作、网络交互等。 触发场景:用户要求搜索信息、查看网页内容、访问需要登录的网站、操作网页界面、抓取社交媒体内容(小红书、微博、推特等)、读取动态渲染页面、以及任何需要真实浏览器环境的网络任务。

Other39

Browse the most popular Claude skills, all other skills, or write your own with the skills generator.