Pedantic Review
Read-only craft review of changed code and test design: reuse, placement, complexity, and repository conventions. Requirements, coverage sufficiency, execution, and fixes have separate owners.
Install
npx skills add flurdy/agent-skills --skill pedantic-reviewgit clone --depth 1 https://github.com/flurdy/agent-skills.git /tmp/agent-skills
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cp -r /tmp/agent-skills/skills/pedantic-review ~/.claude/skills/pedantic-reviewPersonal skills live in ~/.claude/skills. Use .claude/skills in a project folder to share a skill with your team.
From the SKILL.md
# Pedantic Review An opinionated **read-only craft review**, not a second requirements or correctness gate. Compare changed code with repository practice before recommending a cleaner design. No automatic fixes. ## Ownership | Question | Owner | |---|---| | Is the plan coherent? | `architect` | | Implement or repair the behavior? | `develop` / `implement-solution`, separately authorized | | Does the implementation meet requirements; are tests adequate and passing? | `verify-task` | | Does it format and lint? | `clean-code` | | Is the craft any good? | `pedantic-review` | | Is the exact PR correct and supported by review evidence? | `review-pr` | | What independent claims merit validation? | `second-opinion` | Do not run those workflows automatically. Reuse a supplied scope/requirements packet; never replace a caller's revision with the default branch diff. A craft verdict cannot clear the overall review, prove requirements satisfied, establish coverage sufficiency, or authorize publication. ## Usage
Details
- Skill name
pedantic-review- Repository
- flurdy/agent-skills
- Path
skills/pedantic-review/SKILL.md- License
- MIT
- Repo updated
- 17 November 2026
FAQ
What does the Pedantic Review skill do?
Read-only craft review of changed code and test design: reuse, placement, complexity, and repository conventions. Requirements, coverage sufficiency, execution, and fixes have separate owners.
How do I install the Pedantic Review skill?
skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more): npx skills add flurdy/agent-skills --skill pedantic-review. Skills go in ~/.claude/skills (personal) or .claude/skills (project), and Claude loads them automatically when a task matches the description.
Is Pedantic Review popular?
It lives in flurdy/agent-skills, which has 9 GitHub stars and 0 forks.
Related skills
Architect
9flurdy/agent-skills
Architecture and implementation planning gate for complex or high-blast-radius work. Produces evidence-backed decisions, reviewable slices, acceptance evidence, and conditional human review ownership without editing code.
Artifact Hygiene
9flurdy/agent-skills
Run a local-only, read-only advisory audit of publishable working-tree files and unpublished branch history with redaction-safe findings.
Backlog Groom
9flurdy/agent-skills
Auto-detects workspace unfinished backlogs across unique stores; otherwise local open beads. Flags thin prose, missing labels, drift, lifecycle and duplicates. Report-only; mutations need approval, destructive ones individually.
Skills Review
9flurdy/agent-skills
Explicit, skeptical review of a source skill collection. Screens the catalog, tests sampled skills' necessity, and proposes evidence-backed trims, merges, retirements or fixes; read-only until selected findings go to triage.
Diagnose Bug
9flurdy/agent-skills
Evidence-led, read-only bug diagnosis using minimal reproduction, boundary isolation, ranked hypotheses, and explicit falsification tests before any fix is proposed.
Airflow Dag Patterns
9sandbaseai/workbuddy-skill
Use when designing or reviewing Apache Airflow DAGs, task dependencies, sensors, retries, backfills, or pipeline tests.
Browse the most popular Claude skills, all testing & qa skills, or write your own with the skills generator.