Motion Design Critique

Use this skill when something has gone wrong, looks wrong, or needs a second opinion. Triggers on: "something looks off", "this doesn't look right", "why is this happening", "script error", "render artifact", "the timing feels wrong", "animation looks robotic", "AE error", "bpy error", "Blender crashed", "nothing is moving", "wrong position", "wrong keyframe", "expression error", "the material looks fake", "shadows are wrong", "why does this look cheap", "critique this", "review this", "what's wrong with". Also triggers when the user is stuck and doesn't know why. Works with or without MCP att

43 stars 8 forksFrontend & Design

Install

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more)
npx skills add LobzyJay/motion-design-with-claude-and-codex --skill motion-design-critique
Manual install
git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/LobzyJay/motion-design-with-claude-and-codex.git /tmp/motion-design-with-claude-and-codex
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cp -r /tmp/motion-design-with-claude-and-codex/skills/motion-design-critique ~/.claude/skills/motion-design-critique

Personal skills live in ~/.claude/skills. Use .claude/skills in a project folder to share a skill with your team.

From the SKILL.md

# Motion Design Critique

You are a senior motion designer doing a diagnostic. Something is wrong. Your job is to find it and fix it, not to soften the feedback.

## What you are not

- Not a sympathetic listener. Don't validate the problem, fix it.
- Not vague. "The easing feels off" is not useful. Name the specific parameter, the specific frame, the specific value. Give the fix.
- Not a tutorial. The user is a designer. They want the diagnosis and the patch, not a lesson.
- Not guessing. If you don't have enough information to diagnose, ask for the one thing you need: a screenshot at a specific time, an error message, a state dump, the script that ran. One question, not five.

## Diagnostic modes

**Mode 1. Visual critique.** The output looks wrong. The user has a screenshot or a description.
Load `references/visual-diagnostics.md`. Identify the specific problem. Give the fix.

**Mode 2. Script / expression error.** A JSX script or bpy script threw an error. The user has an error message.
Load `references/ae-diagnostics.md` (for AE) or `references/blender-diagnostics.md` (for Blender). Find the error pattern. Give the patch.

**Mode 3. Motion quality review.** The animation runs but feels wrong: robotic, default, weightless, overly mechanical.
Load `references/visual-diagnostics.md`. Run through the defaults-to-avoid checklist. Name every problem you see. Rank by impact. Fix the highest-impact ones first.
Read the full skill on GitHub

Details

Skill name
motion-design-critique
Path
skills/motion-design-critique/SKILL.md
License
MIT
Repo updated
23 September 2026

FAQ

What does the Motion Design Critique skill do?

Use this skill when something has gone wrong, looks wrong, or needs a second opinion. Triggers on: "something looks off", "this doesn't look right", "why is this happening", "script error", "render artifact", "the timing feels wrong", "animation looks robotic", "AE error", "bpy error", "Blender crashed", "nothing is moving", "wrong position", "wrong keyframe", "expression error", "the material looks fake", "shadows are wrong", "why does this look cheap", "critique this", "review this", "what's wrong with". Also triggers when the user is stuck and doesn't know why. Works with or without MCP att

How do I install the Motion Design Critique skill?

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more): npx skills add LobzyJay/motion-design-with-claude-and-codex --skill motion-design-critique. Skills go in ~/.claude/skills (personal) or .claude/skills (project), and Claude loads them automatically when a task matches the description.

Is Motion Design Critique popular?

It lives in LobzyJay/motion-design-with-claude-and-codex, which has 43 GitHub stars and 8 forks.

Related skills

Aftereffects Motion

43

LobzyJay/motion-design-with-claude-and-codex

Use this skill whenever Adobe After Effects is the working tool. Triggers on "After Effects", "AE", ".aep", "ExtendScript", "JSX", "composition", "comp", "keyframe in AE", "AE expression", "render queue", "wiggle", "loopOut", "Trim Paths", or any AE-driven motion graphics task. Also triggers when the user is mid-session with the AE MCP bridge active (mcp-bridge-auto.jsx), or mentions "Higgsfield", "remove background", "reframe", "upscale", "Draw to Edit", or "generate footage" in an AE context. Pair with motion-design (foundation skill) for principles, timing, and taste. AE MCP server: TheLlam

AI, LLMs & Agents

Blender Motion

43

LobzyJay/motion-design-with-claude-and-codex

Use this skill whenever Blender is the working tool. Triggers on "Blender", "bpy", "geometry nodes", "Cycles", "EEVEE", "Principled BSDF", "F-curve", "NLA", "keyframe in Blender", "3D motion graphics", "Blender render", "shape keys", "drivers", or any Blender-driven motion or rendering task. Also triggers on "Higgsfield", "Scene Builder", "blockout", "generate a mesh", "rigged character", "Seedance" in a Blender context. Pair with motion-design (foundation skill) for principles, timing, and taste. Blender MCP server: official Blender Lab MCP at projects.blender.org/lab/blender_mcp. Optional Hi

Images, Video & Audio

Motion Design

43

LobzyJay/motion-design-with-claude-and-codex

Use this skill whenever motion, animation, timing, easing, or composition over time is the subject. Triggers on "animate", "motion", "easing", "timing", "keyframe", "transition", "stagger", "loop", "bounce", "overshoot", "follow-through", "anticipation", "12 principles", "motion hierarchy", "composition for motion". Does NOT trigger on still design, static layout, color theory, or typography in isolation. Pair with aftereffects-motion or blender-motion when a tool is named. Load this first; specialists layer on top.

Frontend & Design

Ncp Admin Frontend

49

zhouda1fu/Ncp.Admin

Follows Vben Admin patterns when developing Ncp.Admin frontend (Vue 3 + Vite + TypeScript + Ant Design Vue). Use when adding or modifying views, API modules, routes, locales, or components in src/frontend/apps/admin-antd.

Frontend & Design12

Ncp Admin Grill Me

49

zhouda1fu/Ncp.Admin

面向 Ncp.Admin 的交互式需求拷问与任务定界技能。用于用户需求含糊、跨前后端/权限/接口/数据迁移/测试边界不清、或实现前需要先把范围和验收条件问透的场景;先持续追问并产出清晰任务卡,再决定转入 cleanddd-requirements-analysis、cleanddd-dotnet-coding 或 ncp-admin-frontend。

Frontend & Design12

Lp Editor

43

sliday/daub

Opinionated UI/UX editor for landing pages and marketing sites. Reviews, plans, and builds high-converting pages using proven conversion patterns. Use when the user asks to review a landing page, plan a landing page, build a landing page, critique a hero section, fix CTAs, improve copy, audit conversion elements, wireframe a page, or asks anything about landing page structure, headlines, social proof, pricing tables, FAQs, or page layout. Also use when the user shares a URL or screenshot of a marketing page and wants feedback, or when building any page meant to convert visitors. Trigger on men

Frontend & Design

Browse the most popular Claude skills, all frontend & design skills, or write your own with the skills generator.