Lfe Plan Critique
Run a 5-lens pre-build critique of the approved active plan before the Builder starts. Acts as the Architect persona, read-only on src/. Writes .plans/plan_critique.md. Use immediately after Brain approves active_plan.md.
Install
npx skills add StChiotis/Library-First-Engineering --skill lfe-plan-critiquegit clone --depth 1 https://github.com/StChiotis/Library-First-Engineering.git /tmp/Library-First-Engineering
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cp -r /tmp/Library-First-Engineering/.agents/skills/lfe-plan-critique ~/.claude/skills/lfe-plan-critiquePersonal skills live in ~/.claude/skills. Use .claude/skills in a project folder to share a skill with your team.
From the SKILL.md
# LFE Plan Critique — Pre-Build 5-Lens Review ## Position in Pipeline - **Phase**: 1.5 (between Architect plan approval and Builder start) - **Persona**: Architect (read-only — no src/ write access) - **Trigger**: Automatically after Brain approves `active_plan.md` — before `/lfe-builder` is invoked - **Next Step**: `/lfe-builder` (on PASS) or `/lfe-architect` revision loop (on BLOCK) ## Mission Stress-test the approved plan from five angles before a single line of code is written. Catch ambiguous acceptance criteria, untestable requirements, domain boundary violations, structural impact, and cross-edit incoherence before they become bugs in `src/`. The five lenses are judgment calls; a mechanical pre-pass (Step 1.5) first surfaces the objective, checkable defects into Lens 2 (glob reach, line-count and existence-check antipatterns) and Lens 5 (orphan-word candidates), so the judgment lenses reason over verified facts rather than guesses. ## Hard Rules 1. **Zero Code Writes**: This skill operates on `.plans/` and `.docs/` only — `src/` stays untouched. 2. **5-Lens Sequential**: Run all five lenses in order, every time — even when an earlier lens passed cleanly. Run the mechanical pre-pass (Step 1.5) first, so Lens 2 and Lens 5 reason over its findings. 3. **Single Output File**: All findings aggregate into one `plan_critique.md` — no per-lens files.
Details
- Skill name
lfe-plan-critique- Repository
- StChiotis/Library-First-Engineering
- Path
.agents/skills/lfe-plan-critique/SKILL.md- License
- MIT
- Repo updated
- 14 July 2026
FAQ
What does the Lfe Plan Critique skill do?
Run a 5-lens pre-build critique of the approved active plan before the Builder starts. Acts as the Architect persona, read-only on src/. Writes .plans/plan_critique.md. Use immediately after Brain approves active_plan.md.
How do I install the Lfe Plan Critique skill?
skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more): npx skills add StChiotis/Library-First-Engineering --skill lfe-plan-critique. Skills go in ~/.claude/skills (personal) or .claude/skills (project), and Claude loads them automatically when a task matches the description.
Is Lfe Plan Critique popular?
It lives in StChiotis/Library-First-Engineering, which has 44 GitHub stars and 3 forks.
Related skills
Lfe Architect
44StChiotis/Library-First-Engineering
Act as the Architect for an LFE-compliant project. Design solutions and draft high-fidelity plans.
Lfe Archivist
44StChiotis/Library-First-Engineering
Act as the Archivist for an LFE-compliant project. Use when a change is approved and needs documentation sync, changelog updates, or pipeline status cleanup.
Lfe Boot
44StChiotis/Library-First-Engineering
Bootstrap an LFE-compliant session. Reads orientation docs, checks for interrupted sessions, and activates the project persona. Use at the start of any session.
Lfe Scout
44StChiotis/Library-First-Engineering
Rapid maintenance for minor fixes (max 3 files). Bypasses the full pipeline for non-architectural content edits.
Lfe Hygiene
44StChiotis/Library-First-Engineering
Conduct a structural audit of the repository to detect "Documentation Drift" or "Spaghetti Files." Use in Phase 5 (Hygiene sub-pipeline, Step 1).
Lfe to Prd
44StChiotis/Library-First-Engineering
Synthesise the grill session output into a structured Product Requirements Document. Use in the Architect sub-pipeline after grill-with-docs completes.
Browse the most popular Claude skills, all writing & content skills, or write your own with the skills generator.