Legal Paper Review

模拟中国法学顶级期刊(如《法学研究》《中国法学》《中外法学》)的匿名同行评审,评估论文的创新性、理论贡献、教义学论证链条与退稿风险,输出结构化审稿意见。本 Skill 只做评价,不替作者修改论文。

Install

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more)
npx skills add Clara-Ren/legal-paper-review --skill legal-paper-review
Manual install
git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/Clara-Ren/legal-paper-review.git /tmp/legal-paper-review
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cp -r /tmp/legal-paper-review/. ~/.claude/skills/legal-paper-review

Personal skills live in ~/.claude/skills. Use .claude/skills in a project folder to share a skill with your team.

From the SKILL.md

# Legal Paper Review

中国法学顶级期刊论文审稿评价 Skill。

## 用途

- 模拟《法学研究》《中国法学》《中外法学》等期刊的匿名外审流程;
- 判断论文的创新性、理论贡献、教义学论证链条质量与退稿风险;
- 输出结构化、可复盘的审稿意见。

**本 Skill 只负责评价,不负责修改论文。** 所有审稿意见以"问题诊断 + 攻击理由"的形式输出,由作者自行决定是否采纳、如何修改。

## 核心流程

按以下顺序执行审稿:

1. **范式识别**——先判断论文属于哪种研究范式(民法教义学/社科法学/行业问题导向等),避免用错误的学科范式评价论文。
2. **编辑初审模拟**——站在期刊编辑视角做第一轮筛选判断。
3. **核心命题压力测试**——对论文的中心命题做最强反驳(steelman attack)。
4. **Reviewer Persona 多角色审稿**——调用 [reviewer-personas.md](reviewer-personas.md) 中的四类审稿人视角分别审查。
5. **多维攻击审查**——从十个维度系统攻击论文论证(维度定义见 [review-discipline.md](review-discipline.md))。
6. **顶刊价值判断**——对照 [top-journal-aesthetic.md](top-journal-aesthetic.md) 的审美标准评估发表价值。
7. **拒稿风险识别**——对照 [rejection-patterns.md](rejection-patterns.md) 中的六类典型退稿模式逐项排查。
8. **综合审稿意见**——按 [output-template.md](output-template.md) 的固定结构输出最终意见。

## 评审纪律

评审全过程受 [review-discipline.md](review-discipline.md) 约束,核心包括:

- **防谄媚**:不得为了讨好作者而降低攻击强度;
- **最强反驳**:必须给出能成立的最强反对意见,而非稻草人;
- **范式自觉**:不得用错误学科范式评价论文;
- **Frame Lock Detection**:识别论文是否被某个框架锁死而看不见替代路径;
- **Surface Form Parity**:对不同作者、不同立场的论文保持同一攻击强度;
- **严重性控制**:区分致命问题、重大问题、轻微问题,不夸大也不缩小。

评审必须攻击论证,而非作者;不得将个人学派偏好伪装为客观缺陷。

## 扩展模块

### socio-legal-integration-module.md

当论文试图将法社会学、法经济学等社会科学融入法教义学时,在"多维攻击审查"之外**叠加** [socio-legal-integration-module.md](socio-legal-integration-module.md),检验:

- 融入是否经过教义学的筛选与过滤,而非把经验观察直接接到规范结论上;
- 是否明示了外部学科的能力限度;
- 主张改变既有教义的,是否承接了相应的论证负担。

## 文件说明

| 文件 | 作用 |
|------|------|
| `SKILL.md` | 入口与流程编排(本文件) |
| `review-discipline.md` | 评审纪律层:防谄媚、最强反驳、范式自觉等 |
Read the full skill on GitHub

Details

Skill name
legal-paper-review
License
MIT
Repo updated
12 August 2026

FAQ

What does the Legal Paper Review skill do?

模拟中国法学顶级期刊(如《法学研究》《中国法学》《中外法学》)的匿名同行评审,评估论文的创新性、理论贡献、教义学论证链条与退稿风险,输出结构化审稿意见。本 Skill 只做评价,不替作者修改论文。

How do I install the Legal Paper Review skill?

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more): npx skills add Clara-Ren/legal-paper-review --skill legal-paper-review. Skills go in ~/.claude/skills (personal) or .claude/skills (project), and Claude loads them automatically when a task matches the description.

Is Legal Paper Review popular?

It lives in Clara-Ren/legal-paper-review, which has 15 GitHub stars and 0 forks.

Related skills

Industry Chain Research

12

ivanyinjc-blip/industry-chain-research

产业链深度研究 9 段对齐 skill(2026-07-06 v4.1:在 8+1 之前加 chain-radar 行业雷达)。 基于「齐码.SKILL」Design-by-Contract 思想 + harrischen/invest 多因子评分 + zhangmusinb/gushifenxi 深度研究方法,形成「周期 × 缺口 × 政策」三角定位法。 每段输入=上段产物,实现"结论=证据"的全链路对齐。 包含三层价值量(成本/利润/瓶颈)、三类缺口(瓶颈/增量/国产替代/新需求)、 反证条件、跟踪指标。聚焦 A 股 + 港股 + 美股产业链投研。

Research & Science

Academic Figures

15

sai-tv/academic-figures

Generate professional, publication-ready scientific figures as editable SVG files for academic journals (Nature, Science, Cell, ACS, IEEE, Elsevier). Use this skill whenever the user wants to create a schematic figure, graphical abstract, TOC graphic, experimental workflow diagram, conceptual illustration, multi-panel figure, or any visual for a research paper or presentation. Also trigger when users mention "figure for paper", "journal figure", "scientific illustration", "panel figure", "graphical abstract", "TOC graphic", "schematic diagram", "Inkscape", "Ipe editor", or requests for publica

Research & Science

Zotero Search

12

urschrei/zotero_search_skill

Search the user's local Zotero library, find related papers via Semantic Scholar, and discover citations/references. **Claude Code only** - this skill requires a local Zotero instance and access to a port on localhost. Use when the user asks to search their Zotero library, find papers on a topic, explore citations of a paper, or find related literature. Supports cross-referencing Semantic Scholar results against the local library.

Research & Science

Academic Revision Checklist

13

JimmyRaoUF/academic-revision-checklist

Reader-first revision of academic English (dissertation chapters, abstracts, papers, defense slides). Finds the sentences a first-time reader stops at, fixes them in the author's voice, and turns each fix into a rule checked across the whole document. 66 checks from 60+ revision rounds of one HCI dissertation, a 16-item quick list, reading protocols, and a script that lists candidates for the mechanical checks. Use when revising or checking academic writing, when a text reads like AI, or when one reader comment should be applied everywhere. 修改或检查英文学术写作(博士论文、摘要、期刊论文、答辩讲稿):找出第一次读的人会卡住的句子,按作者的口吻改

Research & Science

Lead Research Brief

10

Luispitik/lead-research-brief

Investiga un lead comercial B2B, mapea sus procesos operativos AS-IS y genera el backlog de una app a medida. Entrega 3 artefactos (resumen en chat + HTML interactivo + Word) y opcionalmente una demo-app funcional con datos sintéticos y branding del cliente (Fase 6). USAR SIEMPRE cuando el usuario diga "investiga este lead", "haz el brief de", "prepara la propuesta para", "genera el mapa de procesos de", "brief_investigacion", o proporcione un formulario de lead con organización, sector o problema.

Research & Science

Paper Review

16

jam-cc/paper-review.skill

Review ML/AI research papers, critique contributions and experiments, write referee reports, or self-review before submission. Use for requests such as 'review this paper', 'what are the weaknesses', 'help me referee', '审稿', '写审稿意见', '评审这篇论文', '帮我审', or '投稿前自审'. Also use to improve an existing review or verify its references.

Research & Science

Browse the most popular Claude skills, all research & science skills, or write your own with the skills generator.