Double Crux

CFAR rationality technique for resolving disagreements by finding shared underlying belief divergence points (cruxes). Use when the user wants to: (1) resolve a disagreement by finding the real point of contention, (2) prepare for a difficult conversation by mapping belief structure, (3) practice collaborative truth-seeking, (4) examine beliefs by finding what would change their mind, or (5) facilitate a structured disagreement between two positions. Triggers: "double crux", "disagree", "what would change my mind", "crux", "resolve disagreement", "find the real issue", "belief examination", "C

5 stars 1 forksOther

Install

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more)
npx skills add EquiStamp/CFAR-Claude-Skills --skill double-crux
Manual install
git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/EquiStamp/CFAR-Claude-Skills.git /tmp/CFAR-Claude-Skills
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cp -r /tmp/CFAR-Claude-Skills/double-crux ~/.claude/skills/double-crux

Personal skills live in ~/.claude/skills. Use .claude/skills in a project folder to share a skill with your team.

From the SKILL.md

# Double Crux

A CFAR technique for resolving disagreements by collaboratively finding the underlying belief (the "crux") that drives both parties' positions. A crux is a fact that, if believed differently, would change your conclusion.

## Three Modes

1. **Design Mode** — Prepare for a disagreement by mapping belief structure and identifying likely cruxes
2. **Practice Mode** — Walk through Double Crux on a practice topic to build skill
3. **Execute Mode** — Facilitate real-time Double Crux on a live disagreement

## Prerequisites

Double Crux requires: genuine willingness to change one's mind, excitement about getting closer to truth, emotional safety, and epistemic humility. If prerequisites aren't met, acknowledge this and suggest alternatives.

## Core Process

### Step 1: Identify the Disagreement
Find a statement A where parties genuinely disagree. Confirm it's real, not semantic.

### Step 2: Operationalize
Move from abstract to concrete:
- Attach numbers: "very likely" → "70% probable"
- Define observable outcomes: "economy improves" → "GDP growth > 3%"
- Make claims falsifiable: "How would we know if this were true or false?"

### Step 3: Seek Cruxes
Each party independently identifies cruxes — beliefs such that changing them would change their position on A. Key question: "If [belief B] were false, would you change your mind about A?"

A **double crux** is a belief B where both parties disagree about B AND B causally influences both positions on A.
Read the full skill on GitHub

Details

Skill name
double-crux
Path
double-crux/SKILL.md
Repo updated
5 February 2026

FAQ

What does the Double Crux skill do?

CFAR rationality technique for resolving disagreements by finding shared underlying belief divergence points (cruxes). Use when the user wants to: (1) resolve a disagreement by finding the real point of contention, (2) prepare for a difficult conversation by mapping belief structure, (3) practice collaborative truth-seeking, (4) examine beliefs by finding what would change their mind, or (5) facilitate a structured disagreement between two positions. Triggers: "double crux", "disagree", "what would change my mind", "crux", "resolve disagreement", "find the real issue", "belief examination", "C

How do I install the Double Crux skill?

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more): npx skills add EquiStamp/CFAR-Claude-Skills --skill double-crux. Skills go in ~/.claude/skills (personal) or .claude/skills (project), and Claude loads them automatically when a task matches the description.

Is Double Crux popular?

It lives in EquiStamp/CFAR-Claude-Skills, which has 5 GitHub stars and 1 forks.

Related skills

Aversion Factoring

5

EquiStamp/CFAR-Claude-Skills

CFAR rationality technique for decomposing aversions into specific addressable components using the LEGO brick model. Use when the user: (1) avoids something they believe they should do, (2) says "I hate doing X" and wants to understand why, (3) wants to overcome a specific aversion, (4) practice decomposing emotional resistance, or (5) wants to understand the gap between what they want to want and what they actually want. Triggers: "aversion factoring", "I hate", "I avoid", "I can't make myself", "why do I resist", "overcome aversion", "ugh field", "CFAR", "decompose aversion".

Frontend & Design

Bucket Errors

5

EquiStamp/CFAR-Claude-Skills

CFAR rationality technique for identifying where you've entangled questions that should be separate, causing you to flinch away from evidence. Use when the user: (1) feels defensive about acknowledging something true, (2) conflates unrelated beliefs ("Am I a good writer?" with "Did I spell this correctly?"), (3) has trouble accepting feedback, (4) wants to practice detecting question substitution, or (5) notices they avoid thinking about certain topics. Related to Kahneman's attribute substitution. Triggers: "bucket error", "conflating", "flinching away", "defensive about", "question substitut

Writing & Content

Focusing

5

EquiStamp/CFAR-Claude-Skills

Gendlin's Focusing technique adapted by CFAR for accessing pre-verbal bodily knowledge ("felt sense") to gain insight on problems. Use when the user: (1) feels stuck and analytical thinking isn't helping, (2) wants to understand what they really feel about something, (3) needs to access intuition or gut feelings, (4) wants to check if their intellectual conclusions match their deeper sense, (5) is doing Internal Double Crux and needs to access each side's felt sense, or (6) wants to practice body awareness for better decision-making. Triggers: "focusing", "felt sense", "what do I really feel",

Other

Auth Implementation Patterns

9

huytran1120/vietnam-agentic-skills

Implement or review authentication and authorization with explicit token, session and resource-access boundaries.

Other

Freedom of Action

5

EquiStamp/CFAR-Claude-Skills

CFAR rationality technique for identifying where default frames artificially constrain perceived options and expanding the action space. Use when the user: (1) feels stuck with no good options, (2) wants to identify artificial constraints on their choices, (3) needs to expand their perceived action space, (4) feels obligated rather than choosing, (5) wants to explore what a "fair bid" from a situation looks like, or (6) wants to practice noticing where they've stopped considering alternatives. Triggers: "freedom of action", "no good options", "feel stuck", "feel obligated", "what are my option

Other

Audit Preparation

9

huytran1120/vietnam-agentic-skills

Audit preparation register: required document, period covered, request and receipt dates, preparer and reviewer, auditor queries and adjustments. Use for assembling an audit file.

Other

Browse the most popular Claude skills, all other skills, or write your own with the skills generator.