Dialectical Mapping Steelmanning
Applies thesis-antithesis-synthesis reasoning to escape false binary choices by steelmanning opposing positions, mapping their underlying principles and tradeoffs, and synthesizing principled third-way resolutions. Use when debates are trapped in false dichotomies, polarized positions need charitable interpretation, tradeoffs are obscured by binary framing, synthesis beyond "pick one side" is needed, or when users mention steelman arguments, Hegelian dialectic, or resolving seemingly opposed principles.
Install
/plugin marketplace add lyndonkl/claudeThe repo is a Claude Code plugin marketplace. Run /plugin afterwards to pick the plugin that includes this skill.
npx skills add lyndonkl/claude --skill dialectical-mapping-steelmanninggit clone --depth 1 https://github.com/lyndonkl/claude.git /tmp/claude
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cp -r /tmp/claude/skills/dialectical-mapping-steelmanning ~/.claude/skills/dialectical-mapping-steelmanningPersonal skills live in ~/.claude/skills. Use .claude/skills in a project folder to share a skill with your team.
From the SKILL.md
# Dialectical Mapping & Steelmanning ## Table of Contents - [Workflow](#workflow) - [Common Patterns](#common-patterns) - [Guardrails](#guardrails) - [Quick Reference](#quick-reference) ## Workflow Copy this checklist and track your progress: ``` Dialectical Mapping Progress: - [ ] Step 1: Frame the debate - [ ] Step 2: Steelman Position A (Thesis) - [ ] Step 3: Steelman Position B (Antithesis) - [ ] Step 4: Map principles and tradeoffs - [ ] Step 5: Synthesize third way - [ ] Step 6: Validate synthesis quality ``` **Step 1: Frame the debate** Identify the topic, the two polarized positions (Thesis vs Antithesis), and the apparent tension. Clarify why this feels like a binary choice. See [Common Patterns](#common-patterns) for typical debate structures. **Step 2: Steelman Position A (Thesis)** Present Position A in its strongest form: underlying principle (what it values), best arguments (strongest case for this position), supporting evidence, and legitimate tradeoffs it accepts. Use [resources/template.md](resources/template.md#steelmanning-template) for structure. Avoid strawmanning—present version that adherents would recognize as fair. **Step 3: Steelman Position B (Antithesis)** Present Position B in its strongest form with same rigor as Position A. Ensure symmetry—both positions get charitable treatment. See [resources/template.md](resources/template.md#steelmanning-template). **Step 4: Map principles and tradeoffs**
Details
- Skill name
dialectical-mapping-steelmanning- Repository
- lyndonkl/claude
- Path
skills/dialectical-mapping-steelmanning/SKILL.md- Repo updated
- 1 September 2026
FAQ
What does the Dialectical Mapping Steelmanning skill do?
Applies thesis-antithesis-synthesis reasoning to escape false binary choices by steelmanning opposing positions, mapping their underlying principles and tradeoffs, and synthesizing principled third-way resolutions. Use when debates are trapped in false dichotomies, polarized positions need charitable interpretation, tradeoffs are obscured by binary framing, synthesis beyond "pick one side" is needed, or when users mention steelman arguments, Hegelian dialectic, or resolving seemingly opposed principles.
How do I install the Dialectical Mapping Steelmanning skill?
Claude Code plugin: /plugin marketplace add lyndonkl/claude. Skills go in ~/.claude/skills (personal) or .claude/skills (project), and Claude loads them automatically when a task matches the description.
Is Dialectical Mapping Steelmanning popular?
It lives in lyndonkl/claude, which has 200 GitHub stars and 25 forks.
Related skills
Abstraction Concrete Examples
200lyndonkl/claude
Builds structured abstraction ladders that translate high-level principles into concrete, actionable examples across 3-5 levels. Bridges communication gaps, reveals hidden assumptions, and tests whether abstract ideas work in practice. Use when explaining concepts at different expertise levels, moving between abstract principles and concrete implementation, identifying edge cases by testing ideas against scenarios, designing layered documentation, decomposing complex problems into actionable steps, or bridging strategy-execution gaps.
Academic Letter Architect
200lyndonkl/claude
Guides the creation of evidence-based academic recommendation letters, reference letters, and award nominations that combine concrete examples, meaningful comparisons, and genuine enthusiasm. Use when writing recommendation letters for students, postdocs, or colleagues, or when user mentions recommendation letter, reference, nomination, letter of support, endorsement, or needs help with strong advocacy and comparative statements.
Adr Architecture
200lyndonkl/claude
Documents significant architectural and technical decisions with full context, alternatives considered, trade-offs analyzed, and consequences understood. Creates a decision trail that helps teams understand why decisions were made. Use when choosing between technology options, making infrastructure decisions, establishing standards, migrating systems, or when user mentions ADR, architecture decision, technical decision record, or decision documentation.
Echo Skill Inline
117Peiiii/skild
Second bundled skill (inline dependency) for kitchen-sink skillset.
Delete User
109BerriAI/litellm-skills
Delete one or more users from a live LiteLLM proxy. Ask for the user_id(s) and confirm before calling POST /user/delete.
Fail2ban
213TerminalSkills/skills
Protect servers from brute force attacks with Fail2Ban. Use when a user asks to block repeated failed login attempts, protect SSH, secure web servers from brute force, or ban malicious IPs automatically.
Browse the most popular Claude skills, all other skills, or write your own with the skills generator.