Devil Advocate
Constructive critic and stress-tester for PM ideas, proposals, and strategies. Use when you want to challenge an idea before presenting it, find weaknesses in a PRD or proposal, anticipate objections from leadership or engineering, or strengthen a pitch by addressing counter-arguments upfront.
Install
/plugin marketplace add tarunccet/pm-skillsThe repo is a Claude Code plugin marketplace. Run /plugin afterwards to pick the plugin that includes this skill.
npx skills add tarunccet/pm-skills --skill devil-advocategit clone --depth 1 https://github.com/tarunccet/pm-skills.git /tmp/pm-skills
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cp -r /tmp/pm-skills/pm-product-strategy/skills/devil-advocate ~/.claude/skills/devil-advocatePersonal skills live in ~/.claude/skills. Use .claude/skills in a project folder to share a skill with your team.
From the SKILL.md
# Devil's Advocate ## Purpose Strengthen ideas by systematically finding their weaknesses. This is not about being negative — it's about helping PMs build more resilient proposals by identifying gaps, anticipating objections, and suggesting mitigations before stakeholders do. This is different from a pre-mortem (which focuses on launch risks in pm-execution). Devil's advocate challenges the idea itself — its assumptions, logic, and positioning — at any stage from early concept to final proposal. ## Context You are a constructive critic stress-testing **$ARGUMENTS**. If the user provides documents (PRDs, proposals, decks, strategy docs), read them carefully before challenging. ## Instructions ### Phase 0: Context Confirmation Before proceeding, review what's been provided in $ARGUMENTS and the conversation context. **Only ask about what's missing — don't re-ask what's already clear.** 1. **Summarize** what you understand from the provided context — restate the product, market, or situation back to the user in 2-3 sentences. 2. **Identify gaps** — if any of the following are unclear, ask: - What idea, proposal, or strategy are we challenging? - What is the strongest argument in its favor? - Who is the audience for this critique (internal team, exec stakeholders)? 3. **Confirm**: _"Here's my understanding: [summary]. I plan to [brief description of what the skill will produce]. Does this look right, or would you like to adjust anything before I proceed?"_
Details
- Skill name
devil-advocate- Repository
- tarunccet/pm-skills
- Path
pm-product-strategy/skills/devil-advocate/SKILL.md- License
- MIT
- Repo updated
- 13 November 2026
FAQ
What does the Devil Advocate skill do?
Constructive critic and stress-tester for PM ideas, proposals, and strategies. Use when you want to challenge an idea before presenting it, find weaknesses in a PRD or proposal, anticipate objections from leadership or engineering, or strengthen a pitch by addressing counter-arguments upfront.
How do I install the Devil Advocate skill?
Claude Code plugin: /plugin marketplace add tarunccet/pm-skills. Skills go in ~/.claude/skills (personal) or .claude/skills (project), and Claude loads them automatically when a task matches the description.
Is Devil Advocate popular?
It lives in tarunccet/pm-skills, which has 9 GitHub stars and 2 forks.
Related skills
Ab Test Analysis
9tarunccet/pm-skills
Analyze A/B test results with statistical significance, sample size validation, confidence intervals, and ship/extend/stop recommendations. Use when evaluating experiment results, checking if a test reached significance, interpreting split test data, or deciding whether to ship a variant.
Adr
9tarunccet/pm-skills
Document architecture and product decisions using the Nygard ADR format — captures context, alternatives considered, and consequences so the team never asks 'why did we do it this way?' again. Use when making architecture decisions, choosing between technical approaches, selecting vendors, or any decision that will be hard to reverse.
AI Build Buy Partner
9tarunccet/pm-skills
Evaluate AI capability sourcing options across build, buy, fine-tune, and partner archetypes using a structured decision matrix. Use when deciding whether to build a custom model, use an LLM API, fine-tune a base model, or partner with an AI vendor.
Funnel Analysis
9tarunccet/pm-skills
Analyze a conversion funnel — identify drop-off points, calculate stage-by-stage conversion rates, generate leakage hypotheses, and recommend improvement experiments. Use when diagnosing funnel performance, prioritizing optimization work, or designing experiments to improve conversion.
Brainstorm Ideas Existing
9tarunccet/pm-skills
Brainstorm product ideas for an existing product using multi-perspective ideation from PM, Designer, and Engineer viewpoints. Use when generating new feature ideas, brainstorming solutions for an identified opportunity, or ideating with a product trio.
Opportunity Solution Tree
9tarunccet/pm-skills
Build an Opportunity Solution Tree (OST) to structure product discovery — map a desired outcome to opportunities, solutions, and experiments. Based on Teresa Torres' Continuous Discovery Habits. Use when structuring discovery work, mapping opportunities to solutions, or deciding what to build next.
Browse the most popular Claude skills, all other skills, or write your own with the skills generator.