Abt Narrative Critique

Evaluate research proposals and papers using the And-But-Therefore (ABT) storytelling framework from Olson's 'Houston, We Have a Narrative'. Calibrated for environmental science and urban climate research. Use when: (1) User asks to critique or evaluate a research proposal introduction/abstract, (2) User asks to assess whether a paper's framing is compelling for publication, (3) User wants feedback on narrative structure of scientific writing, (4) User mentions ABT framework, Olson, or 'Houston We Have a Narrative'. Provides qualitative critique with severity assessment (fatal vs. improvable),

5 starsResearch & Science Plugin marketplace

Install

Claude Code plugin
/plugin marketplace add kangning-huang/science_narrative_skills

The repo is a Claude Code plugin marketplace. Run /plugin afterwards to pick the plugin that includes this skill.

skills CLI (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex and more)
npx skills add kangning-huang/science_narrative_skills --skill abt-narrative-critique
Manual install
git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/kangning-huang/science_narrative_skills.git /tmp/science_narrative_skills
mkdir -p ~/.claude/skills
cp -r /tmp/science_narrative_skills/abt-narrative-critique ~/.claude/skills/abt-narrative-critique

Personal skills live in ~/.claude/skills. Use .claude/skills in a project folder to share a skill with your team.

From the SKILL.md

# ABT Narrative Critique

Evaluate scientific writing using the And-But-Therefore framework. Focuses on introductions and abstracts of research proposals and papers in environmental/urban science.

## The ABT Framework

Scientific narratives follow: **AND** (context) → **BUT** (tension) → **THEREFORE** (resolution)

- **AND**: Establishes what we know. Cites relevant literature to frame the problem.
- **BUT**: Identifies the critical gap. Creates tension that demands resolution.
- **THEREFORE**: Proposes the solution. Shows how methods/results address the gap.

## Workflow

### 1. Determine Document Type
- **Research proposal**: Forward-looking; "Therefore" focuses on proposed methods and expected contributions
- **Research paper**: Retrospective; "Therefore" includes results and demonstrated impact

See [references/proposal-criteria.md](references/proposal-criteria.md) or [references/paper-criteria.md](references/paper-criteria.md) for type-specific evaluation criteria.

### 2. Extract ABT Components
Parse the introduction/abstract to identify:
- AND section: Background statements, cited literature, established knowledge
- BUT section: Gap statement, tension, "however/but/yet" pivot
- THEREFORE section: Proposed approach, methods justification, expected/demonstrated outcomes

### 3. Evaluate Each Component

#### AND Evaluation
1. **Citation coverage**: Extract all cited works. Search for each using Hugging Face paper search and web search to verify:
Read the full skill on GitHub

Details

Skill name
abt-narrative-critique
Path
abt-narrative-critique/SKILL.md
Repo updated
18 January 2026

FAQ

What does the Abt Narrative Critique skill do?

Evaluate research proposals and papers using the And-But-Therefore (ABT) storytelling framework from Olson's 'Houston, We Have a Narrative'. Calibrated for environmental science and urban climate research. Use when: (1) User asks to critique or evaluate a research proposal introduction/abstract, (2) User asks to assess whether a paper's framing is compelling for publication, (3) User wants feedback on narrative structure of scientific writing, (4) User mentions ABT framework, Olson, or 'Houston We Have a Narrative'. Provides qualitative critique with severity assessment (fatal vs. improvable),

How do I install the Abt Narrative Critique skill?

Claude Code plugin: /plugin marketplace add kangning-huang/science_narrative_skills. Skills go in ~/.claude/skills (personal) or .claude/skills (project), and Claude loads them automatically when a task matches the description.

Is Abt Narrative Critique popular?

It lives in kangning-huang/science_narrative_skills, which has 5 GitHub stars and 0 forks.

Related skills

Abt Narrative Critique Zh

5

kangning-huang/science_narrative_skills

使用ABT(And-But-Therefore,即「而且-但是-因此」)叙事框架评估中文科研项目申请书和论文。该框架源自Randy Olson的《Houston, We Have a Narrative》。专为环境科学和城市气候研究领域校准。使用场景:(1) 用户要求评估或点评中文项目申请书的摘要或引言部分,(2) 用户想评估论文框架是否具有发表竞争力,(3) 用户需要科学写作的叙事结构反馈,(4) 用户提到ABT框架、Olson或NSFC/国家自然科学基金申请。提供定性评估、问题严重程度判断(致命缺陷vs可改进问题)、引文核查和建设性修改建议。

Other

Mock Exam Builder

5

aq7zo/mock-exam-builder

Build or update a self-contained HTML midterms/finals mock exam and per-topic practice quizzes strictly from class materials in a sources/ folder, with clickable citations, exam-based mastery tracking, reorderable sections, and incremental updates.

Research & Science

Meyhem Researcher

4

c5huracan/meyhem

Multi-query research tool with LLM-ranked results and freshness control. Breaks a topic into focused queries, previews top results. No API key.

Research & ScienceIn 1 list

Deep Research

10

artguru-tech-team/claude-skills-public

Multi-source deep research combining YouTube, web search, and article URLs into NotebookLM as a free RAG backend. Use when user wants to research a topic in depth, find up-to-date information, generate analysis, infographics, podcasts, quizzes, or any NotebookLM artifact. Triggers on "research X", "deep dive into X", "find everything about X", or /deep-research.

Research & Science

Cue Us Research

8

sensedeal/cue-skills

用 Cue 跑「美国投研一站式」场景的深度研究:多源公开数据交叉、结论带来源。 Run Cue deep research for the "US Equity Research" scenario. 触发 Triggers: 美国投研一站式、财务与业绩、行情与交易 / US equity research, US macro, US company analysis

Research & ScienceIn 1 list

Apify Market Research

9

huytran1120/vietnam-agentic-skills

Analyze market conditions, geographic opportunities, pricing, consumer behavior, and product validation across Google Maps, Facebook, Instagram, Booking.com, and TripAdvisor.

Research & Science

Browse the most popular Claude skills, all research & science skills, or write your own with the skills generator.